United Nations Capital Development Fund
Search UNCDF.org:


UNDP

International Year of Microcredit 2005

OHRLLS

Development Gateway Foundation

UN Works

MDG Monitor

Français
Search   Employment   Internships   Contact Us   Home  
About Local Development Inclusive Finance Evaluations Technical Advisory Countries Publications News
United Nations Capital Development Fund - Evaluations

1992-1997 UNCDF Project Evaluations - Overall Findings

Prepared by the Policy, Planning and Evaluation Unit (PPEU)

STRENGTHS & WEAKNESSES MATRIX

  1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 Average 1992 - 1997
  + M -- + M -- + M -- + M -- + M -- + M -- STRONG
+%		 MIXED
0%		 WEAK
Project Concept 83 17 0 80 20 0 75 25 0 44 44 11 79 14 7 75 19 6 73 23 4
Formulation/Technical Design 17 67 17 20 70 10 0 75 25 22 22 56 29 29 43 27 46 27 19 48 30
Needs Identification 50 17 33 70 10 20 50 50 0 56 33 11 50 36 14 81 13 6 60 23 14
Accurate/Adequate Basic Data                   56 11 33 14 36 50 44 31 25 38 12 36
Attainment of Immediate Objectives 1/ 17 50 33 20 40 40 50 50 0 11 78 11 36 43 21 64 19 19 33 46 21
Targetting of Beneficiaries 100 0 0 100 0 0 50 25 25 44 44 11 29 43 29 69 25 6 65 22 12
Community Sensitization 67 17 17 40 0 60 67 0 33 25 63 13 29 43 29 46 15 39 46 23 32
Community Participation 0 20 80 20 30 50 33 33 33 43 14 43 38 46 15 50 25 25 31 28 41
Women’s Participation 0 20 80 40 0 60 0 0 100 33 17 50 42 25 33 50 36 14 28 19 56
Appropriate Technical/Equipment Specs 33 17 50 40 10 50 0 75 25 56 11 33 50 8 42 58 25 17 40 31 36
Technical Assistance 0 33 67 40 0 60 0 0 100 67 22 11 54 38 8 36 28 36 33 18 47
Training/Knowledge Transfer 33 17 50 70 0 30 75 0 25 43 57 0 43 29 29 43 36 21 51 20 26
Monitoring and Supervision 17 33 50 50 0 50 50 25 25 89 11 0 43 21 36 50 22 38 50 22 33
Institutional Capacity 67 17 17 40 20 40 75 0 25 22 11 67 57 21 21 38 38 24 50 19 32
Effective Utilization of Outputs 83 0 17 30 30 40 75 25 0 44 44 11 23 54 23 74 13 13 55 22 17
Effective Maintenance 67 17 17 10 60 30 0 75 25 40 20 40 42 50 8 11 33 66 28 38 31
Support to Local Govern/ Decentr.                   0 100 0 67 33 0 38 50 12 35 68 4
Support to Civil Society Strengthening                   80 20 0 64 36 0 80 20 0 75 30 0
Coordination at Project Level 33 17 50 60 10 30 100 0 0 67 11 22 43 21 36 56 6 38 60 13 29
Coordination at District/Sectoral Level 33 0 67 70 0 30 100 0 0 44 11 44 31 23 46 22 22 66 50 12 42
On-time, within budget 17 17 67 30 10 60 50 0 50 78 11 11 14 21 64 31 44 25 37 17 46
Timely Procurement/Recruitment 17 17 67 50 0 50 50 0 50 33 11 56 7 43 50 44 12 44 34 11 53
Performance of UN Cooperating Agency                         55 27 27 38 38 24 47 30 26
Overall Assessment of Evaluators                         57 29 14 62 18 18 60 31 16
TOTAL NUMBER OF EVALUATIONS 7     10     4     9     14     16          

+ = Strength -- = Weakness M= Mixed "blank" = not assessed by evaluators