United Nations Capital Development Fund
Search UNCDF.org:


UNDP

International Year of Microcredit 2005

OHRLLS

Development Gateway Foundation

UN Works

MDG Monitor

Français
Search   Employment   Internships   Contact Us   Home  
About Local Development Inclusive Finance Evaluations Technical Advisory Countries Publications News
United Nations Capital Development Fund - Evaluations

1997 Project Evaluation Results

Prepared by the Policy, Planning and Evaluation Unit (PPEU)

STRENGTHS & WEAKNESSES MATRIX

  BHU/88/C02 LES/87/C05 MAG/92/C01 MLW/93/C02 RAF/94/C01 BHU/92/C03 LAO/89/C04 MOZ/89/C02 SEN/87/C03 TOG/85/C06
Microfinance Microfinance Microfinance Microfinance Microfinance Roads Roads Roads Roads Education
Final Final Mid-Term Final Final Final Final Mid-term Final Final
Project Concept + + + M + M + + + +
Formulation/Technical Design M -- M -- + -- + M + M
Needs Identification + + + -- + M M + + +
Accurate/Adequate Basic Data M -- M -- + + M + + M
Attainment of Immediate Objectives 1/ + -- + -- + -- + M + +
Targetting of Beneficiaries + M + M + M M + + +
Community Sensitization -- -- + M + --   + M --
Community Participation n/a -- + M + -- + + n/a M
Women’s Participation M + + M + -- M M n/a  
Appropriate Technical/Equipment Specifications + n/a n/a n/a   M + M + +
Technical Assistance + -- + -- + -- + M n/a --
Training/Knowledge Transfer + -- + M + M M -- n/a M
Monitoring and Supervision + -- + -- + -- + -- + +
Institutional Capacity + M M -- + -- M -- + +
Effective Utilization of Outputs + M + -- + -- + + + +
Effective Maintenance n/a n/a n/a n/a   M M M -- --
Support to Local Governance/ Decentralization n/a M n/a M   + M M n/a n/a
Support to Civil Society Strengthening n/a n/a n/a +   + n/a n/a n/a n/a
Coordination at Project Level + -- + -- + -- + + + +
Coordination at District/Sectoral Level + -- n/a --   M + -- M n/a
On-time , within budget M M + M + -- + + M M
Timely Procurement/Recruitment + -- + -- + M + -- M +
Performance of UN Cooperating Agency n/a M + -- M M +   + M
Overall Assessment by Evaluators + -- + -- + -- + M + +

+ = Strength       -- = Weakness       M= Neither       n/a = Not applicable to project design       "blank" = not assessed by evaluators

1/ not applicable for mid-term evaluations

(Return to top)

  BDI/87/C05 LAO/89/C01 SEN/87/C02 SUD/87/C04 BEN/88C03 NER/87/C04        
Habitat Habitat Water Supply Water Supply Int. Rural Devt Int. Rural Devt ------------------------
No. of evals
assessing
the theme
------------------------
Mid-Term Final Final Final Mid-Term Final   STRONG
+%		 MIXED
0%		 WEAK
--%
Project Concept + + -- + + M 11 75 19 6
Formulation/Technical Design + M -- M   M 10 27 46 27
Needs Identification + + + + + + 11 81 13 6
Accurate/Adequate Basic Data + -- -- M + + 11 44 31 25
Attainment of Immediate Objectives 1/ M + + M + + 11 64 19 19
Targetting of Beneficiaries + + -- + + + 11 69 25 6
Community Sensitization   + + --   + 8 46 15 39
Community Participation   + M --   + 12 50 25 25
Women's Participation M + + -- + + 14 50 36 14
Appropriate Technical/Equipment Specifications + + -- + M -- 12 58 25 17
Technical Assistance n/a M M M + -- 14 36 28 36
Training/Knowledge Transfer n/a + + M + -- 14 43 36 21
Monitoring and Supervision + + -- -- M M 11 50 22 38
Institutional Capacity M + + M M -- 11 38 38 24
Effective Utilization of Outputs + + M + + + 11 74 13 13
Effective Maintenance   + -- --   -- 9 11 33 66
Support to Local Governance/ Decentralization n/a + n/a + n/a -- 8 38 50 12
Support to Civil Society Strengthening + + n/a 0 n/a   5 80 20 0
Coordination at Project Level + -- -- + M -- 11 56 6 38
Coordination at District/Sectoral Level n/a -- n/a -- n/a n/a 9 22 22 66
On-time , within budget M -- M -- + -- 16 31 44 25
Timely Procurement/Recruitment + -- -- -- + -- 11 44 12 44
Performance of UN Cooperating Agency + M --   + -- 13 38 38 24
Overall Assessment by Evaluators + + + M + M 11 62 18 18

+ = Strength       -- = Weakness       M= Mixed       n/a = Not applicable to project design       "blank" = not assessed by evaluators

1/ not applicable for mid-term evaluations