Microfinance Newsletter Image of women working UNCDF logo 2005: Year of Microcredit
colorful bar

UNITED NATIONS CAPITAL DEVELOPMENT FUND    Microfinance

Issue 3 / May - June 2004

     

Past Issues

Voices of Microfinance

Thank you to all those who contributed their expertise to provide valuable insight into the following question:

**What is the most valid and reliable indicator of how good a country’s financial sector is at meeting the needs of its population?


It is a very difficult question that depends on economies we are in and what do we measure ourselves against. However, when asked to provide up to 6 sentences, my choice is in following:

Each country should have a developed financial sector that has outreach and diversified product range offered to all citizens.

So, this implies that a country should have a developed financial sector - different financial institutional forms committed to the best performance practice and transparency - so citizens are able to have services within their reach, within their communities, and at their doorstep.

The financial sector should ensure that citizens have different products to select from and that there is a channel through which it is possible to shape the market with various mechanism (code of conduct, transparency codes...) - so trust is built in financial institutions.

— Nejira Nalic
Director
Microcredit Organisation MI-BOSPO Tuzla (Bosnia and Herzegovina)



The key issues that help identify the healthiness of a country's financial sector may lie in the following checklist:
· Does the importance given to savings mobilization represent a clear potential to endogenous growth?
· Do donor credit lines serve the development of diversified financial products (institutional approach) instead of exclusive outreach?
· Does a country enable financial institutions to establish their fees and interest rates in relation to their products' transactional costs?
· How many diversified products are available to entrepreneurs and consumers?
· Do institutions leverage commercial borrowing or investments and do instruments such a loan guarantee schemes enable it?
· What is the overall and per income strata, volume of financing outstanding in comparison with the physical assets of the country?
Answers to these basic questions can quickly give valuable insight about a country's financial sector.

— Guy Dionne
Economic Development Coordinator
Srebrenica Regional Recovery Programme (SRRP)
UNDP (Bosnia and Herzegovina)


A good financial sector is one that is extensive in terms of value and volume of transactions and which has diversified financial services to serve a spectrum of development activities and different segments of a society.

An effective financial sector has a legal and regulatory institutional framework that is consistent, and flexible to accommodate micro-financing institutions, leasing and venture capital activities and development of financial institutions.

A financial sector should be credible and have a strategy for savings mobilization – accessibility to all segments of society, and diversified financial instruments.

The financial sector should also have the capacity to undertake a macro and micro economic analytical work to maintain and sustain macroeconomic stability with stable exchange rates, interest rates and controlled inflations that gives people confidence to save and invest.

A sector needs a credit delivery system that reaches beyond the major towns and capital cities to include the promotion of policies that valorize assets such as land and buildings for securitization purposes.

A sector should have efficient, secure and swift payment systems that encourage acceptance of non-cash modes of payment.

Finally, a sector must contribute to the strengthening and the promotion of business and training institutions to build a critical mass of high quality professionals capable of effectively management.

In my opinion, a financial sector that is not inclusive of the poor (which in most cases in Africa constitute the majority) will not and cannot be a sound, dynamic sector.

— Nardos Bekele-Thomas
UNDP, Country Program Advisor, Regional Bureau for Africa


The percentage of the population that has access to a savings account in a formal financial institution (i.e., one that is overseen, directly or indirectly by government regulators) would be a pretty useful indicator. Not everyone wants or needs a loan, but if the financial sector is reaching out and extending savings services to the bulk of the population, that would be beneficial.

— Bernd Balkenhol
International Labor Organization (ILO)


My suggestion would be to use the percentage of the households in the country/region with access to institutional financial services (measured with account in a financial institution, credit line, line of credit or credit card).

— Bernardo Guillamon
International Develpoment Bank (USA)


A good financial sector is the one that earns the trust from the population and can be easily accessed both by poor and rich without any sex, age, race, nationality, and religion intolerance.

A good financial sector has all the segments of financial system including banks, leasing companies, insurance agencies, auditing companies and others interrelated and directed towards increasing the quality of serving the population.

A good financial system is the one that uses technology for efficient transactions, including electronic banking and e-commerce to ease the access to funds, including credit and debit cards and correspondent relations with international financial systems.

A good financial sector is the one that has stable and legislative bases for all financial transactions where the population can generate sustainable income, invest, and transfer funds with confidentiality and security.

A good financial sector is the one that can make the appropriate adjustments according to global financial fluctuations in both times of crisis and progress.

A good financial system (public and commercial) can effectively manage the fund transfers from saving into credits, and from tax collections into government expenditures.

— Komuna Djuraeva and Djakhangirdjan Mamadjanov
Center for Economic Research (Uzbekistan)


To me the factor that most indicates how well a country's financial sector is meeting the needs of its people is the depth of it's capital markets and commercial banking sector. Depth refers to soundness (capital adequacy), strength (portfolio quality and product spread), the ability to generate and allocate capital (savings) effectively, a cadre of trained professionals working in the industry, and a regulatory base which operates on the basis of international standards and which adheres to the rule of law (especially as this relates to respecting contracts and providing legal recourse for disputes). Not many developing countries possess all or many of these attributes. Too much of their financial sectors are state owned/controlled. Patronage and corruption are therefore more highly prevalent. And various customer segments are thus underserved, especially low-income groups.

One other major indicator of a country's financial health is whether or not the legal system provides for universal access to capital. Too many countries have not provided the legal/regulatory base which allows citizens to realize the capital stored in their assets, especially hard assets such as real estate which cannot be registered and therefore pledged as collateral except in an underground economy which by nature is limited and inefficient. The amount of wealth stored in such assets, especially those controlled by the poor, is often a major part of an LDC's economy yet often lies fallow as a source of liquidity and economic growth.

— Bob Eichfeld
former CEO of Citibank South Asia and current Grameen Foundation USA board member
Chair of India Advisory Council and Capital Markets Committee


Development has four (4) main issues: education, employment, health and access to credit. Even though the microfinance industry has been growing in most countries around the world, the percentage of those with access to credit is still very low. So one valid and reliable indicator will be the percentage of financial services devoted to the Micro and Small Enterprises in relation to a country’s GNP.

— Manuel Montoya
President, Vision Consultoria (Peru)


The most valid and reliable indicator of how good a country’s financial sector is in meeting the needs of its population is the level of per capita income and the stability of that income. For income to grow, it must be rooted in the balance of trade and commerce of the nation. In practical terms, the balance of trade and commerce will translate into the steady decline of the unemployment rate over a period of time thereby generating more income overall.

— Reverend Kortu K. Brown
Chairman, Concerned Christian Community (Liberia)